A dispute over trail entrance access in the Beechtree neighborhood has caused significant tension between residents and property owner Keith Myers. The disagreement stems from a long-standing easement that the HOA claims gives residents the right to use the trail. However, Myers argues otherwise.
Dispute Over Trail Entrance Causes Tension
The conflict began when a video showing Keith Myers jackhammering the trail entrance on Montibello Drive surfaced online. The entrance lies between two properties that Myers owns.
Residents, including Ian Pearthree, were upset by Myers’ actions. Pearthree’s family has lived near the trail since the 1990s. His mother expressed her emotional connection to the trail, sharing that it holds fond memories of her late husband.
The trail, accessible for over 30 years, was created as part of an easement granted by the neighborhood’s developer. The HOA maintains that all association members can use the trail.
Keith Myers, however, disagrees, claiming a quitclaim agreement allows him to do as he pleases with the land. Tensions between Myers and the Pearthree family have been ongoing.
Previously, Myers opposed vehicle access to the trail for a landscaping project, despite HOA approval. His involvement with the trail continued as he admitted to placing concrete bollards on the path. Legal disputes followed, with both parties filing lawsuits accusing each other of harassment, trespassing, and emotional distress.
Legal Action and HOA Involvement
The HOA, represented by attorney Weldon Jones, firmly rejects Myers’ claims of ownership over the easement. Jones explained that the easement benefits all homeowners, regardless of the land it crosses. As the legal battle continues, Cary town officials clarified that property disputes like this are private matters for the courts to decide.
Currently, an injunction prevents Myers from blocking access to the trail. However, a court hearing is scheduled to address the issue further. If unresolved soon, the dispute could escalate to a jury trial later this year.
